Most people who get charged with affray have never heard the word before. It is not a term that comes up in everyday conversation, and the charge often catches people completely off guard. One moment you are in a heated confrontation outside a pub or at a party, and the next you are being told by police that you are being charged with affray.

Despite its unfamiliarity, affray is a serious criminal offence in NSW. It carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment, and it is one of the charges police regularly lay in situations involving public violence or threatening behaviour. If you have been charged with affray, understanding the offence and what options are available to you is critical.

What Is Affray?

Affray is an offence under section 93C of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). A person is guilty of affray if they use or threaten unlawful violence towards another person, and their conduct is such as would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for their personal safety.

There are a few important things to unpack in that definition.

First, affray involves the use or threat of unlawful violence. This means the charge can be laid even if no one was actually hit or injured. Threatening behaviour alone is enough, provided it meets the required standard.

Second, the test is objective. It does not matter whether anyone at the scene was actually afraid. The question is whether a hypothetical reasonable person, if present, would have feared for their safety. This means the charge can apply even if the only people present were willing participants in the confrontation.

Third, affray can be committed in a public or private place. Unlike some public order offences, affray is not limited to conduct in public. A violent confrontation at a private house party can result in an affray charge just as easily as a fight in a pub car park.

When Do Police Charge Affray?

Police typically lay affray charges in situations involving street fights (particularly outside pubs, clubs, and late night venues), brawls involving multiple people, violent confrontations at parties or gatherings, road rage incidents that escalate to threats or violence, and public disturbances involving aggressive or threatening behaviour.

Affray is often charged alongside other offences such as assault occasioning actual bodily harm, common assault, or malicious damage. In situations where a fight breaks out and it is unclear exactly who hit whom, police may charge everyone involved with affray because the offence captures the overall violent conduct rather than requiring proof of a specific assault on a specific person.

This is one of the reasons affray catches people off guard. You might not have thrown a punch, but if you were actively involved in a threatening confrontation, that can be enough.

What Are the Penalties for Affray?

The maximum penalty for affray is 10 years imprisonment. If the matter is dealt with in the Local Court (which is common for less serious instances), the maximum penalty is capped at 2 years imprisonment.

In practice, the sentence depends heavily on the circumstances. Factors the court will consider include the level of violence or threat involved, whether weapons were used, the number of people involved, the location (offences in busy public areas are viewed more seriously), whether anyone was injured, the duration of the incident, the accused’s role (whether they were an instigator or a lesser participant), and the accused’s criminal history.

For a first offender involved in a brief, spontaneous confrontation with no injuries and no weapons, a non custodial outcome is realistic. Conditional release orders, community correction orders, and fines are all possible. For more serious incidents involving sustained violence, weapons, or injuries, custodial sentences including intensive correction orders or full time imprisonment are on the table.

The court will apply the aggravating and mitigating factors under the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 in determining the appropriate sentence.

Can I Get a Section 10 for Affray?

A conditional release order without conviction (formerly section 10) is possible for affray, particularly for first offenders in less serious cases. The court will consider the nature and seriousness of the offence, your character, your age, your criminal history, the impact a conviction would have on your employment and livelihood, and any steps you have taken toward rehabilitation.

Completing an anger management course, obtaining a favourable psychological report, and gathering strong character references before your court date all improve your chances. A well prepared application from an experienced lawyer is significantly more likely to succeed than an unprepared one.

Possible Defences to Affray

Affray charges can be defended on a number of grounds depending on the facts.

Self Defence

If you used or threatened force because you believed it was necessary to defend yourself or another person, and your response was reasonable in the circumstances as you perceived them, self defence is a complete defence to affray. The test under section 418 of the Crimes Act is the same as for assault offences.

Self defence is particularly relevant in affray cases where you were responding to an attack or threat from someone else and were charged alongside the aggressor.

The Conduct Would Not Cause Fear

Remember, the test for affray requires that the conduct would cause a hypothetical reasonable person to fear for their personal safety. If the conduct was minor, brief, or not genuinely threatening, it may not meet that threshold. A verbal argument that involved raised voices but no physical threats or violence may not satisfy the elements of affray.

Identification

Affray charges often arise from chaotic situations involving multiple people, poor lighting, CCTV footage of varying quality, and conflicting witness accounts. If the prosecution cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that you were the person engaged in the violent or threatening conduct, identification is a viable defence.

This is particularly relevant where police arrived after the incident and relied on witness descriptions or CCTV footage to identify participants.

Lack of Intent

The prosecution must prove that you intentionally used or threatened violence. If the contact was accidental, or if you were trying to break up a fight and became inadvertently involved, this may negate the intent element.

Duress

If you were forced into the confrontation by threats from another person and had no reasonable opportunity to withdraw, duress may provide a defence.

Affray vs Common Assault

People sometimes ask why they were charged with affray instead of common assault, or vice versa. The key difference is that common assault requires proof that force was applied to a specific person without their consent. Affray focuses on the broader conduct and whether it would cause fear to a bystander.

In a situation where two people are fighting, police might charge both with common assault (each assaulting the other) or affray (both engaging in violent conduct that would frighten a bystander), or both. Affray is particularly useful for the prosecution in group situations where it is difficult to prove exactly who assaulted whom, because it captures the collective violent behaviour.

A person can also be charged with affray for threatening violence without actually making physical contact with anyone. You cannot be charged with common assault for mere threats unless the victim apprehended immediate violence.

What Happens in Court

Affray can be dealt with in the Local Court or the District Court, depending on the seriousness of the matter. Most affray charges are dealt with in the Local Court.

If you plead not guilty, the matter will proceed to a defended hearing. The prosecution will typically rely on CCTV footage, police body worn camera footage, witness statements, and any admissions made during a police interview. Your lawyer will cross examine prosecution witnesses, challenge the reliability of the evidence, and present your defence.

If you plead guilty, your lawyer will make submissions on penalty, presenting mitigating factors and supporting material to achieve the most lenient sentence available. Thorough preparation at this stage can mean the difference between a conviction and a conditional release order, or between a community based sentence and full time custody.

Why You Need a Lawyer for Affray

Affray charges carry a maximum of 10 years imprisonment and can result in a criminal record that affects your employment, travel, and future opportunities. The charge is often laid in situations where the facts are contested, the CCTV footage is ambiguous, and the witness accounts are conflicting.

An experienced criminal defence lawyer will review the evidence, identify the strongest defence strategy, and either fight the charge at trial or prepare the most compelling sentencing case possible. If you have been charged with affray, getting legal advice early gives you the best chance of a favourable outcome.

FAQs

What is the maximum penalty for affray in NSW?

The maximum penalty is 10 years imprisonment. If dealt with in the Local Court, the maximum is 2 years.

Can you be charged with affray if you did not hit anyone?

Yes. Affray covers the use or threat of unlawful violence. Threatening behaviour alone is enough if it would cause a reasonable person to fear for their safety.

Is affray a serious charge?

Yes. It is an indictable offence carrying up to 10 years imprisonment. While many cases are dealt with at the lower end, it should not be treated casually. A conviction results in a criminal record for a violence related offence.

Can affray charges be dropped?

Yes. If the evidence is insufficient, if there are identification issues, or if your lawyer negotiates with the prosecution, the charge can be withdrawn or downgraded. Early legal advice gives you the best chance of achieving this.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you have been charged with a criminal offence, contact Davis & Associates for advice specific to your situation.

Call Davis & Associates

If you have been charged with affray in NSW, do not assume the worst. With the right legal representation and thorough preparation, there are real options available. Contact Davis & Associates today.

📍 Forster Office: Suite 2, 12-16 Wallis St, Forster NSW 2428

📞 Call us today on 0438 464 410

📧 Email chris@davisassociates.com.au

🌐 Contact us online